What is IRS Direct File?

The IRS intends the Direct File system to be a government-operated, user-friendly, online tax filing platform that streamlines tax filing, making it more manageable and less time-consuming for individuals and businesses alike.

One key focus of this program is on innovation, particularly in how the IRS procures and implements technology.

In an era when digitization is practically essential to efficiency, this system could also speed up the modernization of IRS systems, enhancing the overall taxpayer experience.

Moreover, the IRS is also trying to gather more information through the Direct File pilot. This involves conducting a comprehensive analysis by an independent third party to understand key areas such as taxpayer satisfaction, cost of implementation, and operational feasibility.

This approach aims to ensure that the system will be developed with a clear understanding of the requirements and potential challenges, thereby increasing its chances of successful implementation and operation.

The cost of implementing such a system is a significant consideration. The IRS estimates that a new Direct Filing system would cost between $64.3 million and $248.9 million a year, depending on the complexity of returns accepted and the number of taxpayers using the system.

Despite the costs, the IRS believes that the potential savings for taxpayers make the Direct File system a worthwhile investment. The agency plans to fund the pilot program and any subsequent full-scale implementation through its budget for systems modernization.

Is Direct File free?

Yes, the IRS Direct File system is a free program.

This initiative is not just about convenience; it’s also about fairness. By offering a free tax filing option, the IRS aims to level the playing field for all taxpayers.

The cost of tax preparation can sometimes be a barrier to filing for low-income individuals. A free system could ensure that everyone, regardless of their income level, has access to the tools they need to file their taxes correctly and efficiently.

What’s more, a government-run system could, theoretically, allow for more transparency and control over the tax filing process. It could potentially reduce the chances of errors or fraud that can sometimes occur with third-party tax preparers.

Who is eligible to use IRS Direct File?

As of this writing, the IRS has yet to decide precisely who will be eligible for the pilot program. Factors the agency may consider include income thresholds or tax situations.

It’s plausible that the IRS will attempt to make the pilot program accessible to as many taxpayers as possible. However, this could be limited by factors such as the complexity of a taxpayer’s financial situation. For those with incredibly complicated filings, professional accounting services may still be the best option.

The agency has also shown interest in integrating state tax filing into the program, as evidenced by a July letter from IRS Commissioner Danny Werfel to states inviting them to participate in the system. This could potentially broaden the program’s reach and relevance, making it a more comprehensive solution for taxpayers.

Interestingly, there is an existing Free File Program, which the IRS does not provide. However, it is also not widely used. This program, which was started in 2002, comprises services offered by seven private companies. About 70% of taxpayers are eligible to use this program due to making $73,000 a year or less. However, only a small fraction, about 4%, uses it.

The IRS Direct File system could be a step forward in the evolution of such programs, increasing usage and accessibility.

Who opposes Direct Files?

The program is not without its critics.

In fact, the IRS has been met with opposition from several parties, most notably for-profit tax preparation businesses.

These businesses, including industry giants like H&R Block and Intuit, the maker of TurboTax, argue the IRS Direct File would give the IRS an unfair competitive edge. The rationale is that the IRS, as a government body, has access to resources and regulatory advantages that private businesses do not. They also argue that the Direct File system is redundant, given that free options for filing simple returns are already provided by private firms.

These companies have spent millions of dollars lobbying against the Direct File system in an attempt to preserve their market share.

Further, pundits such as The Wall Street Journal Editorial Board have voiced opposition to the IRS becoming the tax filer, preparer, and auditor, worrying that by assuming all of these roles, the agency will create conflicts of interest.

Essentially, the IRS would be checking its own work, which could lead to biased assessments and unchecked errors.

Despite this, information from the agency’s Taxpayer Experience Survey (TES), which surveyed thousands of taxpayers, and findings from an independently conducted survey by the MITRE Corporation seems to suggest that public opinion broadly favors the Direct File system.

Additionally, advocacy groups have launched coalitions to promote the move towards a government-run file program, arguing that it is in the public’s best interest.

It is clear that the next steps for the IRS Direct File system will be shaped not only by its technological feasibility and user acceptance but also by the resolution of these socio-political challenges.

What is the future of the IRS Direct File System?

The future of the IRS Direct File system is still uncertain. While the pilot program is set to launch for the 2024 tax season, the full-scale implementation of the system will depend on several variables, including the success of the pilot, taxpayer response, and legislative support.

The IRS’s move to launch a direct tax filing system represents a significant shift in the landscape of tax filing in the United States. While promising, however, the program is still in its early stages. As such, taxpayers can expect further updates and clarifications regarding this innovative initiative.

As the IRS prepares to pilot this program, taxpayers and tax professionals will closely watch its development and impact. Until then, taxpayers are advised to continue using their current tax filing methods and stay updated with the latest developments in the Direct File system.

Would you like some help?

If you are a client and would like to book a consultation, call us at +1 (212) 382-3939 or contact us here to set up a time.

If you aren’t a client, why not? We can take care of your accounting, bookkeeping, tax, and CFO needs so that you don’t have to worry about any of them. Interested? Contact us here to set up a no-obligation consultation.

Stay informed

Interested in receiving updates in your mailbox? Check out our newsletter, full of information you can use. It comes out once every two weeks, and you can register for it below.